In the driver's seat
In the driver's seat
Understanding young adults' driving behaviour
Diana Smart, Suzanne Vassallo, Ann Sanson, Samantha Cockfield, Anne Harris and Warren Harrison
Young adults are consistently over-represented among those injured or killed in traffic accidents. Risky driving behaviours such as speeding, driving when fatigued, and driving under the influence of alcohol are often implicated in these crashes. Although considerable research has examined the driving patterns of this age group, and the situational, structural and legal factors that influence their driving behaviour, much less is known about earlier characteristics or circumstances in young drivers' lives that may have influenced their current driving behaviour.
This report, the product of a collaboration between the Australian Institute of Family Studies (AIFS), the Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV), and the Transport Accident Commission (TAC) of Victoria, addressed this issue using data collected over the course of the Australian Temperament Project.
The Australian Temperament Project (ATP) is a longitudinal community study that has followed the development and wellbeing of a group of Victorian children from infancy to young adulthood. The initial sample comprised 2443 infants (aged 4-8 months) and their parents, who were representative of the Victorian population. Approximately two-thirds continue to participate in the study after 20 years.
Understanding the processes by which young Australians develop into safe or risky drivers is crucial in increasing road safety, minimising harm and maximising positive outcomes for our young people. This report focuses on the personal, family and social characteristics that are linked to differing patterns of driving behaviour, while acknowledging the salient role of situational, mechanical and legal factors that influence driving behaviour.
The report is the culmination of a collaborative project between the Australian Institute of Family Studies, the Royal Automobile Club of Victoria, and the Transport Accident Commission of Victoria.
The focus of the collaboration was the longitudinal community study, the Australian Temperament Project (ATP), which itself is a collaboration between researchers from the Institute, the University of Melbourne and the Royal Children's Hospital. The ATP contains 13 waves of data covering many aspects of life from infancy to early adulthood, collected from a representative sample of 2,443 children and parents.
The collaborative project reported here began in 2001 with the realisation that the forthcoming ATP data collection at 19-20 years would provide a valuable opportunity to examine the learner driver and current driving experiences of young people who had recently become licensed drivers (the legal licensing age for most participants was 18 years of age). As a result, the ATP Young Drivers Study formed part of the ATP's 2002 data collection.
Among the major findings emerging from the ATP Young Drivers Study was that risky driving was still quite prevalent, with speeding and driving when tired found to be particularly common. These behaviours continue to be clear targets for road safety efforts. Encouragingly, certain behaviours such as drink driving and failure to use seatbelts were less common, suggesting that road safety efforts aimed at these behaviours have been effective.
The report also highlights the relevance of personal characteristics to driving behaviour. The small group who later became high risky drivers had been consistently more aggressive, hyperactive, and possessed poorer attention capacities and lower social skills from mid childhood than other young drivers. The report suggests that, in addition to concentrating on skill development, road safety initiatives and driver education programs could be extended to focus on the links between a person's individual style and driving behaviour.
Some high risky drivers had a history of problem behaviour, especially antisocial behaviour and substance use. For these young people, risky driving may be a manifestation of a risky lifestyle. These findings further reinforce current efforts to help children make the best start in life, which may curb the later development of a range of problem behaviours, including risky driving.
On behalf of the three organisations participating in this collaboration, I commend the report In the Driver's Seat: Understanding Young Adults' Driving Behaviour, and am confident that it will be of widespread interest, value and relevance to policy makers, practitioners, and the broader community.
Professor Alan Hayes
Australian Institute of Family Studies
Authors and Acknowledgements
Mrs Diana Smart is a Research Fellow at the Australian Institute of Family Studies, and has been the Project Manager for the Australian Temperament Project since 1988. She has conducted research for the Victorian Education Department's Curriculum and Research Branch and the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology's Education Unit, and has lectured in Psychology at Rusden Teachers College. Diana has a Master of Arts degree in Psychology and Diploma of Education.
Ms Suzanne Vassallo is Research Officer within the Children and Parenting Program at the Australian Institute of Family Studies. In this capacity, she is involved in a number of projects concerned with child and adolescent development including the Australian Temperament Project. Suzanne has a Masters degree in Clinical Psychology. Prior to joining the Institute, Suzanne was a Research Fellow in the School of Psychology at Deakin University.
Associate Professor Ann Sanson is an Associate Professor in the Department of Psychology at the University of Melbourne, where her teaching and research are in the areas of developmental psychology, developmental psychopathology and conflict resolution. She was formerly Acting Director of the Australian Institute of Family Studies, is the Project Director for Growing Up in Australia (the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children) and is a leading investigator in the Australian Temperament Project. Ann is a Fellow of the Australian Psychological Society.
Ms Samantha Cockfield is the Manager, Road Safety at the Transport Accident Commission of Victoria (TAC), one of the key road safety organisations in Victoria. Key functions of the Road Safety Division include the conduct of marketing and public education campaigns addressing high-risk behaviours such as speeding and drink-driving, support for police enforcement activities and research and development projects to lay the foundation for future safety initiatives. Samantha has a Bachelor of Economics degree from Monash University and a Master of Business Administration degree.
Ms Anne Harris is the Chief Behavioural Scientist with the Royal Automobile Club of Victoria. She is responsible for developing road user policy, programs and research projects and has worked within the road safety field since 1995. Anne has a BBSc with Honours in Psychology from La Trobe University and a Master of Business Administration degree.
Mr Warren Harrison is a psychologist and consultant in private practice with more than 15 years experience in road safety research, during which he held senior research positions at VicRoads, the Monash University Accident Research Centre, and ARRB Transport Research. He is a member of the Australian Psychological Society, an associate fellow of the Australasian College of Road Safety, and a member of the International Council on Alcohol, Drugs, and Traffic Safety. His research interests include novice drivers, the use of enforcement to modify driver behaviour, and the application of cognitive psychology to road safety. Warren has a Masters degree in Educational Psychology.
Dr Allison McIntyre is a Research Analyst in the Road Safety Division of the Transport Accident Commission. In this role she conducts research projects and analyses a range of road safety data to support and evaluate TAC's road safety programs. Prior to joining the TAC she worked in the private sector in research in educational and organisational psychology settings. Allison has a PhD in social psychology and a Bachelor of Behavioural Science with Honours.
The authors of this report would like to thank the Royal Automobile Club of Victoria and the Transport Accident Commission of Victoria for providing the opportunity to undertake this collaborative project, which we believe has provided interesting and valuable Australian findings that can inform the development of more effective road safety strategies and policies in Australia.
The leadership and guidance provided over the lifetime of the Australian Temperament Project study by its leading investigators - Associate Professor Ann Sanson (Department of Psychology, University of Melbourne), Professor Margot Prior (Departments of Psychology and Paediatrics, University of Melbourne), Professor Frank Oberklaid (Centre for Community Child Health, Melbourne's Royal Children's Hospital) and Associate Professor John W. Toumbourou (Centre for Adolescent Health, Melbourne's Royal Children's Hospital, and Department of Paediatrics, University of Melbourne) - is particularly acknowledged.
Finally, the authors thank the young people, parents and teachers who have participated in the Australian Temperament Project. Without their loyalty and commitment, this research would not have been possible.
This report is the product of the collaboration between the Australian Institute of Family Studies, the Royal Automobile Club of Victoria, and the Transport Accident Commission of Victoria. The study used data gathered from the Australian Temperament Project (ATP) to identify trends in young adult driving behaviour and factors associated with, and pathways to, unsafe driving behaviours among this age group.
Australian Institute of Family Studies
The Australian Institute of Family Studies is Australia's national centre for research and information on families. Now in its 25th year, the Institute's research on issues that affect family stability and wellbeing play a key role in the development of family policy and informed debate in Australia. The Institute if a statutory authority established by the Australian Government in February 1980.
Royal Automobile Club of Victoria
The Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV) represents over 1.3 million members. The organisation was founded in 1903 and is Victoria's peak motoring organisation. RACV is responsible for informing members of issues relating to motoring and advocating on behalf of members on a range of motoring and safety issues.
Transport Accident Commission of Victoria
The Transport Accident Commission (TAC) is the sole provider of personal injury insurance for transport accidents in Victoria. It funds medical care and support services for people injured in transport accidents. A key role of the TAC is to invest in road safety, primarily via public education campaigns. The TAC has worked closely with other road safety partners to achieve a significant reduction in death and injury on Victoria's roads. A state government owned statutory authority; the TAC was established in 1987.
Australian Temperament Project
The Australian Temperament Project is a large longitudinal study of children's development which began in 1983 with the enrolment of a representative sample of 2443 infants and their families from urban and rural areas of Victoria. The study investigates pathways to psychosocial adjustment from childhood to adulthood and the influence of personal, family and environmental factors. Since early in 2000, the Australian Institute of Family Studies has been collaborating with researchers from the University of Melbourne and the Royal Children's Hospital in this ongoing research project.
Smart, D., Vassallo, S., with Sanson, A., Cockfield, S., Harris, A., & Harrison, W. (2005). In the driver's seat: Understanding young adults' driving behaviour (Research Report No. 12). Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies.
Explores the driving experiences and practices of young Victorian drivers, drawing upon data collected as part of the Australian Temperament Projec
Uses data from the longitudinal Australian Temperament Project to examine patterns of risky driving from the late teens to the late twenties
The second report from the collaborative partnership between the Australian Institute of Family Studies and Crime Prevention Victoria
A report prepared for the Ministerial Advisory Committee on Multicultural and Migrant Education 1987